Monday, November 4, 2013

TEWWG Dialectical Journals #11-20


DJ-11
Janie had spent most of the day under a blossoming pear tree in the back-yard…It stirred her tremendously. – Narrator PG 10

It seems as if Janie is drawn to a symbol of her own blossoming life. She is technically coming into her own as an adult and the pear tree is a reflection of that stage in her life. As she looks into the mystery of the tree, she looks inward to herself. This is also a transition period in her life, between girlhood and adulthood.

DJ-12
De nigger woman is de mule uh de world so fur as Ah can see. – Nanny PG 14

This is a huge foreshadow. Janie experiences this firsthand in her second relationship by her forced store job. It also appears with Logan Killicks when he asks her to help in the yard more and more. This is a reoccurring theme in the book and Janie has to overcome it in order to find self-fufilment. As long as a person allows themselves to be stepped on, they won’t be in a place to rise in the world.

DJ-13
You know, honey, us colored folks is branches without roots and that makes things come round in queer ways. – Nanny PG 16

Nanny is an example of a woman whose been beat down and is still struggling to survive. Her life has been difficult, fist as a slave, then as a single mother, then as a single mother but to a grandchild. Slavery left her without roots and she doesn’t wish the same for Janie. However, what Nanny doesn’t realize is that Janie already has roots, new as they may be. Janie’s life with a loving grandmother gave her roots in the town and a happiness to look back on as she gets older.

DJ-14
Ah don’t want yo’ feathers always crumpled by folks throwin’ up things in yo’ face. – Nanny PG 20

Janie doesn’t really understand Nanny at this point in the story. She hasn’t yet experienced the troubles of adulthood or real hardship. This is a Nanny Life Lesson. Nanny understands that people are cruel and bring others down to make themselves feel better, but Janie doesn’t understand yet. This is normal and Nanny realizes Janie will face it in her life, but hopes to curb the worst of it. It also goes back to the idea that black women have it worse in life than most others.

DJ-15
Dis Love! Dat’s just whut got us pullin’ and uh haulin’ and sweatin’ and doin’ from can’t see in de mornin’ till can’t see at night. – Nanny PG 23

The average person views love as the ultimate happiness, and occasional heart break. Nanny has a more cynicle view of love. To her, love is wielded as a tool for binding others to their will. Nanny picks out one huge flaw of love and that is its ability to be cause great harm. By following love, people especially women, are enslaved. This correlates with a theme of woman empowerment. Love is a blockade to success.

DJ-16
They sat on the boarding house porch and saw the sun plunge into the same crack in the earth from which the night emerged. – Narrator PG 33

This sounds like a huge foreshadow. Janie thinks she leaving a life of unhappiness with one man for an easier, more loving marriage with another. However, it doesn’t seem that she realizes the irony in wanting more freedom and trying to achieve that by marrying another. For her, they are shackles. It also brings up the idea of nature. Pear trees (Janie) thrive in the sunshine and warmth, not in the darkness. Lack of light will wilt plants. Humans are the same, without happiness they also become dour.

DJ-17
Us keeps our own selves down. – Coker PG 39

Although the man who speaks this is talking specifically about white people keeping black people down, it doesn’t just mean one people’s sorrow. People often keep themselves down by thinking they can’t do something or it isn’t their place or a multitude of other excuses. Janie also does this to herself by marrying one man and escaping that marriage by wedding another. She also feels trapped in her position as wife of a mayor to do what is proper. Jody may encourage that sort of thinking, but ultimately it’s Janie who makes herself follow the submissive propriety when she wants more.

DJ-18
…but none had the termerity to challenge him. They bowed down to him rather, because he was all of these things, and then again he was all of these things because the town bowed down. – Narrator PG 50

Jody is a representation of a greater system. People want security and they see him as a certain security. He is smart, a savvy politician, commanding, and confident. These traits are all necessary for a good leader who can keep their position at the head.  However, it also means for the little people that they will never be in charge and will have to follow the leaders dictations. Jody is safety for both Janie and the townspeople, but he is also a prison. For Janie, he is the master of the house and controls her every move, but brings the assurance of food, shelter, and a comfortable lifestyle. The townspeople, have roads, a post office, lights, and other creature comforts in exchange for occasionally being bossed around.

DJ-20
They’s jus some puny humans playin’ round de toes uh Time. – Jody PG 54

While belittling others Jody unwittingly tells Janie a nugget of truth. He meant others were just little things, but being that all humans are very similar, he was speaking about himself as well. Time is much greater than Jody or Janie, as their lives quickly pass. Janie is wasting her time with Jody being miserable in her current situation. Janie’s life-tree may be growing and will eventually die, but for the moment she can still grow bigger instead of dry in Jody’s endless scorn.

No comments:

Post a Comment